Wildlife and Trails Checklist — Step B: Considering alternatives

Planning Trails with Wildlife in Mind

The checklist focuses specifically on wildlife issues of trail planning and is designed to mirror comprehensive planning processes.

by American Trails Staff

The checklist focuses specifically on wildlife issues of trail planning and is designed to mirror comprehensive planning processes. This should make it easier to integrate the information into the ways trails are already being planned. If you are beginning to plan a trail and want to find appropriate ways of including wildlife issues, the checklist will raise important questions through each step of the planning process.

Step B. Considering alternatives

1. Preparing and evaluating alternatives

Create distinctive alternative plans.

  • With this handbook’s rules of thumb as a guide, develop alternative plans that maximize the opportunities and minimize the constraints for wildlife.
  • Especially look for opportunities to coordinate the restoration of degraded habitats.
  • Get professional help preparing and evaluating alternatives, if possible.
  • Where an existing trail is to be improved, alternatives might include different management strategies.

Consider alternatives for trailheads and other support facilities.

  • Sites for trailheads and parking areas are sometime overlooked in evaluating wildlife impacts of trails. They need careful design and review.

Evaluate the alternatives.

  • Conduct an internal evaluation of the alternatives using the goals set earlier.

Ask others to help evaluate the alternatives.

  • Conduct an external evaluation of the alternatives
  • Consult with wildlife biologists or other agency personnel, public, environmental groups, landowners, land managers, and others, as appropriate.
  • Summarize the pros and cons of each alternative.

Select a preferred plan.

  • Review the comments made during the evaluation process and select one of the alternatives or create a hybrid plan incorporating the best qualities of two or more plans.


photo credit: Nathan Anderson, Unsplash

2. Designing the trail

Refine the selected plan.

  • Develop site designs, budgets, and timetables.

Develop management strategies.

  • Consider how the trail will be managed, maintained, and monitored.

Develop an environmental education/ interpretation plan.

  • The plan should explain how to communicate to trail users the specific wildlife issues of this trail.

Develop a volunteer plan.

  • Outline support tasks for involving volunteers in monitoring or managing wildlife.

Conduct a final review of the plan and its components.

  • Review the final plan with a wildlife biologist and other specialists.
  • Make certain all the parts went together in ways that support wildlife.


More articles by this author

More articles in this category

Sustaining Wildlife With Recreation on Public Lands

posted Nov 25, 2023

Humans and wildlife interact in multifaceted ways on public lands with both positive and negative outcomes for each group. When managed well, wildlife-based tourism and other forms of recreation can benefit conservation goals.

Environmental Impacts of Winter Recreation

posted Nov 25, 2023

Regardless of our intentions, many species perceive humans as a threat and respond accordingly. In general, animals respond to threats by first increasing vigilance (time spent looking around versus foraging), and running away if the threat is perceived to be imminent.

Modeling Large-Scale Winter Recreation Terrain Selection with Implications for Recreation Management and Wildlife

posted Nov 24, 2023

Winter recreation is a rapidly growing activity, and advances in technology make it possible for increasing numbers of people to access remote backcountry terrain. Increased winter recreation may lead to more frequent conflict between recreationists, as well as greater potential disturbance to wildlife.

Guidelines for Managing and Restoring Natural Plant Communities along Trails and Waterways

posted Sep 18, 2023

These guidelines are designed to assist resource managers in conducting management activities that enhance the quality of natural plant communities, wildlife habitat, regional landscape integrity and visual quality, particularly as related to planning, development, and maintenance of trails, water trails, and water access sites.

889 views • posted 09/08/2018